
Remington 1858 New Army 5.5"
All makers for the Remington 1858 New Army 5.5"
As of November 2026, 2 makers list holsters for the Remington 1858 New Army 5.5"; none of them lists a light-bearing version.
14 holsters from 2 makers, 14 gun-and-light fits, each recorded from the maker’s own product page; no light-bearing fits recorded.
Stock, read from the makers’ storefronts (separate from the fit claims, which do not depend on it): 13 holsters here have a stock reading, read nightly; 13 available to order, 0 out of stock. Holsters with no reading are unknown, not out of stock.
- El Paso Saddlery (13 holsters, 13 fits) No light-bearing version listed. EPS #44 Outfit (Available to order), EPS 1849 “Californian” Holster (Available to order), EPS 1870 “Slim Jim” Holster (Available to order), EPS 1879 “Texas” (Available to order), EPS 1895 “Hardin” (Available to order), EPS 1920 “Crossdraw” (Available to order), EPS 1920 “Tom Threeperson’s” (Available to order), EPS Doc Holiday Holster (Available to order), EPS Jesse James (Available to order), EPS Pommel Bags with Holster (Available to order), EPS Rio Grande Rig (Available to order), EPS Saddle Bags with Holster (Available to order), EPS The Shootist (Available to order)
- Triple K (1 holster, 1 fit) No light-bearing version listed. Triple K Black Powder Holster
Model not stated: 1 more holster from 1 maker names the Remington-New Army 1858 without saying which size, rail or model. They are not counted above; the list shows them under the line “Model not stated”. Makers: Diamond D Outdoors (1).
Remington 1858 New Army 5.5" holsters with no light: 14 holsters from 2 makers
- El Paso Saddlery EPS #44 Outfit (Available to order), EPS 1849 “Californian” Holster (Available to order), EPS 1870 “Slim Jim” Holster (Available to order), EPS 1879 “Texas” (Available to order), EPS 1895 “Hardin” (Available to order), EPS 1920 “Crossdraw” (Available to order), EPS 1920 “Tom Threeperson’s” (Available to order), EPS Doc Holiday Holster (Available to order), EPS Jesse James (Available to order), EPS Pommel Bags with Holster (Available to order), EPS Rio Grande Rig (Available to order), EPS Saddle Bags with Holster (Available to order), EPS The Shootist (Available to order)
- Triple K Triple K Black Powder Holster
Retention
Retention, as locks counted only where the maker’s page names the device (a thumb break, hood, strap, button or lever; ALS, SLS and GLS one each): No locks 9, 1 lock 5.
- No locks: El Paso Saddlery EPS 1849 “Californian” Holster, El Paso Saddlery EPS 1870 “Slim Jim” Holster, El Paso Saddlery EPS 1879 “Texas”, El Paso Saddlery EPS 1895 “Hardin”, El Paso Saddlery EPS Doc Holiday Holster, El Paso Saddlery EPS Jesse James, El Paso Saddlery EPS Pommel Bags with Holster, El Paso Saddlery EPS Rio Grande Rig, El Paso Saddlery EPS Saddle Bags with Holster
- 1 lock: El Paso Saddlery EPS #44 Outfit, El Paso Saddlery EPS 1920 “Crossdraw”, El Paso Saddlery EPS 1920 “Tom Threeperson’s”, El Paso Saddlery EPS The Shootist, Triple K Triple K Black Powder Holster
Facts about the Remington 1858 New Army 5.5"
- Accessory rail
- No accessory rail
- Caliber
- .44 Black Powder
- Size class
- revolver
- Lights makers name for this gun
- None recorded
- Also listed by makers as
- REMINGTON 1858 5 1.2" (listed as "REMINGTON 1858 5 1.2"" by Triple K)
Maker claims only; nothing is inferred. Fitment data read through 2026-11-20.
Holsters whose makers say they fit most pistols
Not exact fits, and not in any count on this page: each maker describes a class of guns in its own words, quoted on every row, and the Remington 1858 New Army 5.5" falls inside that class by the maker’s own criteria (size class, barrel length, rail). 17 products. Same order as the exact fits: verified makers first, then the page’s sort (Price, in stock first), then maker name. Check the maker’s page before you buy.
Bags and packs: 2 more products, filed under Off-body (bags, packs, bands and inserts), are not in this list. With scripts on, choosing Off-body under How you carry lists them on their own line, Bags and packs, with the maker’s words; they are never counted as exact fits.
Unisex Belly Band For Concealed Carry by Clinger Holsters : One Size Fits All – Compatible with full-size to sub-compact guns and revolvers
Lights: the maker doesn’t mention lights.
Belly Band Holster by Daltech Force : Stacked Gun Pocket to Fit Nearly Any Gun
Lights: the maker doesn’t mention lights.
Core-Defender Belly Band Holster by Elite Survival Systems : Fits small to large frame autos and small to medium frame revolvers
Lights: the maker doesn’t mention lights.
Universal Slide Holster - Genuine Leather Finish by Freedom Protective Gear : Universal Slide Holster fits ANY firearm inside or outside the waistband, left or right handed
Lights: the maker doesn’t mention lights.
Extra Wide 6" Belly Band Holster by Daltech Force : This belly band fits any gun except the largest oversized revolvers
Lights: the maker doesn’t mention lights. Maker’s exclusions: “except the largest oversized revolvers”.
Belly Band Holster with 2 Gun Pockets by Daltech Force : Our unique stacked pockets securely fit any gun except the largest oversized revolvers
Lights: the maker doesn’t mention lights. Maker’s exclusions: “except the largest oversized revolvers”.
Ankle Holster - Gun Only - No Magazines by Freedom Protective Gear : This will fit any gun you can realistically conceal on your ankle
Lights: the maker doesn’t mention lights.
Alaska Guide Creations Holster (Select Colors) by Alaska Guide Creations : The adjustable nature of the of Holster makes it perfect for carrying MOST Compact and Sub-Compact Autos as well as Snub-nose and shorter barrel revolvers.
Lights: the maker says no. Maker’s exclusions: “Will NOT accommodate weapons with optics or lights mounted to them.”.
Ultimate Revolver Holster by Remora Holsters : Fits all revolvers, from Mini North American Arms to larger framed models.
Lights: the maker doesn’t mention lights.
Alaska Guide Creations XL Holster (Select Colors) by Alaska Guide Creations : The adjustable nature of the of XL Holster makes it perfect for carrying MOST Full Size Autos and Revolvers with Shorter Barrels.
Lights: the maker says no. Maker’s exclusions: “Will NOT accommodate weapons with optics or lights mounted to them.”.
Alaska Guide Creations Holster by Alaska Guide Creations : The adjustable nature of the of Holster makes it perfect for carrying MOST Compact and Sub-Compact Autos as well as Snub-nose and shorter barrel revolvers.
Lights: the maker says no. Maker’s exclusions: “Will NOT accommodate weapons with optics or lights mounted to them.”.
Red Dot Holster by Alaska Guide Creations : The adjustable nature of the of Holster makes it perfect for carrying MOST Compact and Sub-Compact Autos as well as Snub-nose and shorter barrel revolvers.
Lights: the maker doesn’t mention lights.
Alaska Guide Creations XL Holster by Alaska Guide Creations : The adjustable nature of the of XL Holster makes it perfect for carrying MOST Full Size Autos and Revolvers with Shorter Barrels.
Lights: the maker says no. Maker’s exclusions: “Will NOT accommodate weapons with optics or lights mounted to them.”.
Hunting Shoulder Holster by Elite Survival Systems : Fits large, scoped revolvers
Lights: the maker doesn’t mention lights.
Elastic Ankle Holster by Front Line : allowing it to accommodate a wide variety of pistols and revolvers
Lights: the maker doesn’t mention lights.
Dragon Fire Elephant Banded Western Revolver Holster by Daltech Force : Fits most revolvers with at least a 3" barrel
Lights: the maker doesn’t mention lights.
Sideloader™ Belly Band Holster (Large gun pocket) by Daltech Force : Large Gun Pocket Fits: Double stack semi-autos like Glocks, XDs, S&W M&P and all J-Frame and larger revolvers
Lights: the maker doesn’t mention lights.