1911 Commander 4.25" No Rail

All makers for the 1911 Commander 4.25" No Rail

As of November 2026, 26 makers list holsters for the 1911 Commander 4.25" No Rail; 2 of them list a light-bearing version, most often for the TLR-6 (trigger guard).

429 holsters from 26 makers, 431 gun-and-light fits, each recorded from the maker’s own product page; lights named for this gun: TLR-6 (trigger guard).

Stock, read from the makers’ storefronts (separate from the fit claims, which do not depend on it): 88 holsters here have a stock reading, read nightly; 88 available to order, 0 out of stock. Holsters with no reading are unknown, not out of stock.

Also built to order for the 1911 Commander 4.25" No Rail: these makers’ order forms offer the gun with any light on the product’s own light menu, listed with JavaScript on: Blackpoint Tactical (1 holster, 58 lights), Falco Holsters (86 holsters, 122 lights), Invader Concepts (1 holster, 26 lights), Urban Carry Holsters (4 holsters, 24 lights).

Model not stated: 681 more holsters from 73 makers name the Ruger SR1911 without saying which size, rail or model. They are not counted above; the list shows them under the line “Model not stated”. Makers: DeSantis (68), Front Line (60), Craft Holsters (48), Urban Carry Holsters (38), Holster Pro (37), Tucker Gunleather (37), Galco (34), El Paso Saddlery (33), CrossBreed (31), Triple K (24), Wright Leather Works (22), 1791 Gunleather (18), Gould & Goodrich (17), Safariland (17), Stoner Holsters (12), SpetzGear (11), Garrett Industries (Silent Thunder) (10), Vedder Holsters (9), TACRIG (8), Diamond D Custom Leather (7), ETW Holsters (7), Mitch Rosen (7), Odin Holsters (7), Active Pro Gear (6), Blackpoint Tactical (6), Fobus (6), Red Hill Tactical (6), Allegiant Holster Co (5), Clinger Holsters (5), Ghost International (4), Legacy Firearms Co (4), QVO Tactical (4), Talon Holsters (4), 4Front Holsters (3), ANR Design (3), Black Scorpion Outdoor Gear (3), Freedom Protective Gear (3), GRITR (3), Houston Gun Holsters (3), PusatHolster (3), Razco Holsters (3), Tenicor (3), Tier 1 Concealed (3), Bitterroot Gunleather (2), Diamond D Outdoors (2), Double-Alpha Academy (2), Gunfighters Inc (2), Kinetic Concealment (2), PHLster (2), Stealth Operator (2), Sticky Holsters (2), Tulster (2), Alien Gear (1), Daltech Force (1), Dark Star Gear (1), DME Holsters (1), EDSHolster (1), Elite Survival Systems (1), Four Brothers Inc (1), Harry's Holsters (1), Hogue (1), Incognito Concealment (1), Invader Concepts (1), JM Custom Kydex (1), KSG Armory (1), L.A.G. Tactical (1), Orpaz Holsters (1), Pinnacle Concealment (1), Recluse Holsters (1), Relentless Tactical (1), SOB Tactical (1), Viridian Weapon Technologies (1), Werkz (1).

1911 Commander 4.25" No Rail holsters with a TLR-6 (trigger guard): 4 holsters from 2 makers

Filter the list to this light

1911 Commander 4.25" No Rail holsters with no light: 427 holsters from 25 makers

Filter the list to this light

1911 Commander 4.25" No Rail holsters built to order: the makers’ order forms

These makers’ order forms let a buyer order the holster for the 1911 Commander 4.25" No Rail with any light on the product’s own light menu (the makers’ own words, read from their order forms; with JavaScript on they are listed with the holsters above).

Lights offered for the 1911 Commander 4.25" No Rail only on the order forms

The order forms, by light menu

Light menu (122 lights): TLR-3, TLR-4, TLR-6 (trigger guard), TLR-7, TLR-7A, TLR-7 Sub 1913, TLR-7 X Sub, TLR-7 HL-X Sub, TLR-7 Sub P365, TLR-8, TLR-8 G, TLR-8X, TLR-8A, TLR-8A G, TLR-9, X300U-A, X300U-B, XC1-B, XSC (Glock 43X/48), XSC (Hellcat), Olight PL-1 Valkyrie, PL-2 Valkyrie, Olight PL-Pro, PL-Mini 2, Olight Baldr Pro, Olight Baldr Pro R, Olight Baldr Mini, Olight Baldr S, Insight M3 LED, LaserMax CenterFire, Glock GTL 10, Nightstick TCM-550XL, Nightstick TWM-850XL, Nightstick TWM-30, TLR-1 (base), TLR-1 HL, TLR-1 HP, TLR-1s, TLR-2, TLR-2 HL, Crimson Trace CMR-204, Crimson Trace CMR-208, Fenix GL19R, Fenix GL22, TLR-8 Sub, Fenix GL06, Inforce WILD 1, Inforce WILD 2, Sig Foxtrot1X, X400U, XSC (P365), Olight PL-3, Olight PL-3S, Crimson Trace LG-459, Sig Foxtrot2, Sig Foxtrot2R, Olight Baldr RL Mini, Olight PL-Turbo, TLR-7 Sub Hellcat, Crimson Trace LG-422, TLR-10, TLR-7 Sub Glock 43X/48, TLR-7X, Olight PL-3R, Crimson Trace CMR-209, Solofish SL-1091, XSC-B, Holosun P.ID, Holosun P.ID Dual, Holosun P.ID Plus, TLR-7 HL-X, Sig Foxtrot365XR, Crimson Trace LG-489, Sig Foxtrot365, ArmaLaser TR5, Crimson Trace CMR-201, XC2, PL-Mini 3, Crimson Trace LG-443, Crimson Trace LG-443G, Crimson Trace LG-436, TLR-1 HL-X, Nightstick TSM-11G, Nightstick TSM-14G, Nightstick TSM-15G, ArmaLaser TR4, Glock GTL II, PL-X Valkyrie, Coast PTX30R, Coast PTX35R, Fenix GL07, Crimson Trace LG-431, Crimson Trace LG-412, Nitecore NPL27, Nitecore NPL35, Nitecore NPL25 GL, TLR-1 HP-X, XC3, Crimson Trace LG-437, Fenix GL19R v2, Nightstick TCM-10, Nightstick TCM-365, TLR-3X, Holosun P.ID-K, TLR-8 HL-X, Olight PL-X GL, ArmaLaser TR2, ArmaLaser TR20, ArmaLaser TR22, ArmaLaser TR23, ArmaLaser TR25, ArmaLaser TR27, ArmaLaser TR28, ArmaLaser TR33, ArmaLaser TR40, ArmaLaser TR7, ArmaLaser TR8, ArmaLaser TR9, Crimson Trace CMR-206, Crimson Trace CMR-207, Crimson Trace LG-499, Sig Foxtrot1

Light menu (24 lights): APLc, Crimson Trace CMR-201, Holosun P.ID, Nightstick TCM-5B, Nightstick TSM-11G, Olight Baldr Mini, Olight Baldr Pro R, Olight Baldr S, Olight PL-Pro, PL-Mini 2, TLR-1 HL, TLR-10, TLR-2, TLR-6 (trigger guard), TLR-7A, TLR-7X, TLR-8 Sub, TLR-8A, TLR-9, Viridian X5L, X300U-A, X300U-B, XC1, XC2

Light menu (26 lights): APLc, Olight Baldr Mini, Olight Baldr Pro R, Olight Baldr S, Olight PL-Pro, PL-2 Valkyrie, PL-Mini 2, TLR-1 (base), TLR-1 HL, TLR-1 HL-X, TLR-1 HP-X, TLR-1s, TLR-7, TLR-7 HL-X, TLR-7 HL-X Sub, TLR-7 X Sub, TLR-7A, TLR-7X, TLR-8, TLR-8 HL-X, TLR-8A, TLR-8X, X300T-A, X300T-B, X300U-A, X300U-B

Light menu (58 lights): APLc, Glock GTL II, Holosun P.ID, Inforce APL Gen 1-2, Inforce APL Gen 3, Inforce WILD 2, Olight Baldr Mini, Olight Baldr Pro, Olight Baldr Pro R, Olight Baldr S, Olight PL-Pro, PL-2 Valkyrie, PL-Mini 2, PL-X Valkyrie, Sig Foxtrot1X, Sig Foxtrot2, Sig Foxtrot2R, Sig Foxtrot365XR, TLR-1 (base), TLR-1 HL, TLR-1 HL-X, TLR-1 HP-X, TLR-10, TLR-2, TLR-3, TLR-4, TLR-6 (trigger guard), TLR-7, TLR-7 HL-X, TLR-7 HL-X Sub, TLR-7 Sub 1913, TLR-7 Sub Glock 43X/48, TLR-7 Sub Hellcat, TLR-7 Sub P365, TLR-7A, TLR-8, TLR-8 HL-X, TLR-8 HL-X Sub, TLR-8 Sub, TLR-8A, TLR-9, X200, X300 (original), X300T-A, X300T-B, X300U-A, X300U-B, X400U, XC1, XC1-B, XC1-C, XC2, XC3, XH35, XSC (Glock 43X/48), XSC (Hellcat), XSC (P365), XSC-B

Retention

Retention, as locks counted only where the maker’s page names the device (a thumb break, hood, strap, button or lever; ALS, SLS and GLS one each): No locks 296, 1 lock 141, 2+ locks 1.

Facts about the 1911 Commander 4.25" No Rail

Accessory rail
No accessory rail
Caliber
.45 ACP / 9mm
Size class
compact
Lights makers name for this gun
TLR-6 (trigger guard) (2 makers)
Trigger-guard-mounted lights named
TLR-6 (trigger guard)
Also listed by makers as
1911 4.25" Non-Railed (Maker states 4.25in/Commander and no rail), 1911 1911 4.25" Non-Rail (Maker states 4.25in/Commander and no rail), 1911 - 4.25" NO RAIL (Maker states 4.25in/Commander and no rail), 1911 4" Commander No Rail (Maker states 4.25in/Commander and no rail), Colt 1911 4" Commander No Rail (Maker states 4.25in/Commander and no rail), 1911 without rail 4 25in not sig (Maker states 4.25in/Commander and no rail), 1911 Non-Railed Mil-Spec 4.25" (Maker states 4.25in/Commander and no rail), 1911 4.25" Commander Model Non-Rail (listed as "1911 4.25" Commander Model Non-Rail" by Rounded Gear), Rock Island GI MS (listed as "Rock Island GI MS" by We The People Holsters), Nighthawk Custom T3 (listed as "Nighthawk Custom T3" by Red Hill Tactical, Urban Carry Holsters, We The People Holsters; Officer frame with a 4.25in barrel (CCO pattern: the holster shell follows the 4.25in slide, precedent Dan Wesson Vigil CCO / Rock Ultra CCO -> Commander 4.25)), Nighthawk Custom Border Special (listed as "Nighthawk Custom Border Special" by Red Hill Tactical, Urban Carry Holsters; branded single-stack 1911), Nighthawk Custom Kestrel (listed as "Nighthawk Custom Kestrel" by Red Hill Tactical, Urban Carry Holsters; branded single-stack 1911), Nighthawk Custom Talon II (listed as "Nighthawk Custom Talon II" by Red Hill Tactical, Urban Carry Holsters; branded single-stack 1911), Nighthawk Custom Vice President (listed as "Nighthawk Custom Vice President" by Red Hill Tactical, Urban Carry Holsters; branded single-stack 1911), Ed Brown Kobra Carry (listed as "Ed Brown Kobra Carry" by Craft Holsters, Urban Carry Holsters; 4.25in Commander slide on a Commander Bobtail frame; the maker's full feature list names no rail (Ed Brown names its railed 1911s for the rail: Special Forces Lightrail, SOCOM Edition)), Les Baer Stinger (listed as "Les Baer Stinger" by Craft Holsters, Urban Carry Holsters; Officer-style grip frame with the Commanche (4.25in) top end (CCO pattern -> Commander 4.25); feature list names no rail; the GT Monolith Stinger (full-length dust cover) is listed apart by Urban Carry), Les Baer Concept (VII, VIII) (listed as "Les Baer Concept (VII, VIII)" by Urban Carry Holsters; both Commanche (4.25in) Concepts), Les Baer Custom Carry Comanche (listed as "Les Baer Custom Carry Comanche" by Urban Carry Holsters; Custom Carry at 4 1/4in Commanche length)

Maker claims only; nothing is inferred. Fitment data read through 2026-11-20.

Holsters whose makers say they fit most pistols

Not exact fits, and not in any count on this page: each maker describes a class of guns in its own words, quoted on every row, and the 1911 Commander 4.25" No Rail falls inside that class by the maker’s own criteria (size class, barrel length, rail). 45 products. Same order as the exact fits: verified makers first, then the page’s sort (Price, in stock first), then maker name. Check the maker’s page before you buy.

Bags and packs: 35 more products, filed under Off-body (bags, packs, bands and inserts), are not in this list. With scripts on, choosing Off-body under How you carry lists them on their own line, Bags and packs, with the maker’s words; they are never counted as exact fits.

✓ maker states it✗ maker excludes it– not stated claim not yet human-revieweddate read 90+ days ago
data read through 2026-11-20maker claims only · unknown ≠ nobrandsmakersaboutfor makerscontactcreditsprivacyTrademarks belong to their owners. CarryMatch is not affiliated with or endorsed by any manufacturer.